SCHOLARS SAID3 — SCHOLARS SAID (halal stocks & ETFs desk)
What the Scholars' Standards Actually Say: Apple Passes, Microsoft Splits the Screeners, and One Alphabet With Three Labels
Scholars Said desk — Friday 23 October 2026
Ask ten apps whether a famous stock is halal and you may get three different answers — about the same company, in the same year. That is not a scandal. It is what happens when honest standards differ. This desk exists so our readers can see which standard, whose screen, and as of when — the three questions that turn a label into information.
First, how the screening works
Screeners work in two steps. Step one is the business itself: a company whose core business is alcohol, gambling, conventional banking or insurance, pork, tobacco, weapons or adult entertainment is out before any maths. Step two is financial ratios — how much interest-bearing debt the company carries, how much of its money sits in interest-bearing places, and how much of its income comes from non-compliant sources [1][2].
The famous numbers differ by standard:
- AAOIFI (Shariah Standard No. 21, as publicly summarised): debt below 30% of market capitalisation, interest-bearing deposits below 30%, prohibited income below 5% of revenue [1]. (AAOIFI's full standard text is members-only; these figures are from public summaries of it, and we say so.)
- Dow Jones Islamic Market Index (DJIM): ratios must be below 33%, measured against a trailing average market capitalisation (24 months in the current methodology document), with impure income capped at 5% [3].
- The IFG / Mufti Taqi Usmani-style screen: non-compliant income under 5%, but the debt test is about 33% of total assets — a different measuring stick entirely — plus tests the others omit, such as illiquid assets of at least 20% of total assets [4].
Same company, three rulers. Remember that when you read any verdict.
Three famous names, three different stories
Apple (AAPL). Musaffa's academy, applying AAOIFI standards on the Musaffa platform, classified Apple as halal as of January 2026, noting a small part of its services revenue may need purification (donating the non-compliant share to charity) [5]. Zoya's published halal-stock list also included Apple with a compliance pass, while flagging its growing services — Apple Music and Apple TV content — as a point to keep monitoring, and stating it reviews a stock's status at least quarterly [6].
Microsoft (MSFT) — the screeners disagree. Musaffa classified Microsoft as not halal on its platform as of January 2026, pointing to financial ratios — including interest income earned on its very large cash balance — and its gaming revenue mix; Musaffa itself noted that other screeners classify Microsoft differently because methodologies differ [5]. Zoya's public page labels Microsoft "questionable," reporting about $3.3B of interest income on about $331.8B of revenue for its financial year ending June 30, 2026 (about 0.99%) [7].
Alphabet / Google (GOOGL) — one company, three labels. Musaffa: doubtful, as of May 2026. A secondary report of Zoya's view: questionable. Canadian Halal Investor: PASS, in October 2026, citing interest-bearing debt at 1.23% of market cap and interest income at 1.08% of revenue [5][8][9]. All three can be honest at once — they used different rulers, on different dates.
The halal ETFs, and who watches over them
- SPUS (SP Funds S&P 500 Sharia Industry Exclusions ETF, US): tracks an S&P 500 Shariah index with extra exclusions; 240 holdings as of February 28, 2026; annual expenses 0.45%. Screening for its index is performed by Ratings Intelligence Partners with a Shariah supervisory board of five Islamic scholars, and its manager, ShariaPortfolio, publishes a dividend-purification calculator for investors [10][11].
- HLAL (Wahed FTSE USA Shariah ETF, US, trading since 2019): tracks the FTSE USA Shariah Index, whose constituents are screened by Yasaar Limited under a fatwa issued by Yasaar's principals; expense ratio 0.50% [12][13]. (Note: Wahed's own current fund page was not located in this research, so these facts rest on launch coverage and fund-profile sources — we flag that rather than hide it.)
- SPRE (SP Funds S&P Global REIT Sharia ETF, US): screened property (REIT) companies only — 44 holdings across 10 countries as of February 28, 2026; expenses 0.50% [14].
- WSHR (Wealthsimple Shariah World Equity Index ETF, Canada): tracks a Dow Jones Islamic index weighted by risk rather than size; 0.5% management fee. Wealthsimple states the fund is certified by Ratings Intelligence Partners' researchers, holds a fund fatwa certificate reviewed by a committee of Shariah scholars, excludes derivatives and short selling, and publishes dividend-purification figures quarterly [15].
Where scholars genuinely disagree
- The threshold itself: 30% or 33%? [1][3][4]
- The denominator: market value, or total assets? A spot figure, or an average over 12, 24 or 36 months? Ask any screener: 30% or 33% — of what, averaged over how long? [3][16]
- Purification: does it apply only to dividends, or also to capital gains? Islamic Finance Guru documents this as a real difference of opinion and presents purifying both as the safer course — its view, labelled as such [4].
- Edge cases: payment networks such as Visa and Mastercard are treated by Musaffa as fee-based infrastructure, not interest-lending card issuers [5]; and even the DJIM methodology material notes there is no universal scholarly consensus on some sectors, such as tobacco and defence, though most boards exclude them [3].
The Bulale rule for reading any label
A "halal" label is shorthand. It always means: passed platform X's screen, under standard Y, on date Z. On this desk we will always print all three — and when screeners disagree about the same company, we will print the disagreement, not pick a winner in secret.
Notice
Analysis and information only. A screening result is data, not a fatwa, and nothing here is investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any stock or fund. For a ruling on your own situation, consult a qualified scholar; for learning, courses live at Bulale Academy.
References (accessed 23 Oct 2026)
- HalalScreener — stock screening pages (AAOIFI Standard 21 summary). halalscreener.app
- SP Funds — Combined Prospectus, Mar 29, 2024. sp-funds.com
- S&P Dow Jones Indices — Dow Jones Islamic Market Indices Methodology. (methodology PDF)
- Islamic Finance Guru — "How to Buy Halal Stocks: Stock Screening Method." islamicfinanceguru.com
- Musaffa Academy — "Halal Stocks in the MSCI World Index" (classifications as of Jan–May 2026). academy.musaffa.com
- Zoya Blog — "Top-Rated Halal Stocks." blog.zoya.finance
- Zoya — Microsoft (MSFT) public stock page. zoya.finance
- HalalWallet — "Is Google (Alphabet) Stock Halal? 2026." halalwallet.us
- Canadian Halal Investor — Halal Stock Verdicts (Alphabet PASS, Oct 2026). canadianhalalinvestor.com
- SP Funds — SPUS Summary Prospectus, Mar 30, 2026. sp-funds.com
- SP Funds — Combined Prospectus (Ratings Intelligence Partners; board of five scholars). sp-funds.com
- FA Magazine — "Shariah-Based ETF Arrives in U.S." (HLAL launch; Yasaar). fa-mag.com
- Barchart — HLAL fund profile (expense ratio 0.50%). barchart.com
- SP Funds — SPRE Summary Prospectus, Mar 30, 2026. sp-funds.com
- Wealthsimple — WSHR product page & newsroom (certification, fatwa certificate, purification). wealthsimple.com
- Ratings Intelligence Partners — Shariah Screening methodology page. ratingsintelligence.com
Excluded from this article on purpose: two claims found in secondary material that we could not verify against a primary source (an alleged September 2026 S&P methodology change, and a Malaysian standards change). Unverified means unpublished here.
END OF BATCH 01 — 3 articles: Editorial · News & Market Update · Scholars Said. Drafts for Abdifatah's approval — nothing published.